TEACHING · ACADEMIC WORK

Build an argument
and write

Write a sentence in your own words, cite the evidence directly and use permitted AI feedback to make a specific revision.

QUESTIONS
SUPPORT WITH EVIDENCE
JUSTIFY

How do I turn a source into a paragraph of my own?

Start with your claim
Write down the point you want to make.
Add the exact source location
Record the text, page or table where a reader can check it.

A straightforward results sentence

The example
The AI said 50 MB. The “Campus printing” section of the IT service handbook sets a maximum of 20 MB.
Your own text
Add what this single case shows about your research question.
Permitted feedback
Ask for feedback on unclear sentences. Check any proposed change against the evidence.

Write and check your paragraph

  1. Start the sentence yourself

    Put the main claim in your own words.

  2. Add the source location

    Name the title and page where readers can verify the claim.

  3. Check the feedback

    Look at the original before adopting a change.

A prompt you can adapt

In my paragraph [my own text I am permitted to share], flag one unclear point and one point that needs evidence. Ask me one follow-up question about each.

Quick check Can I show readers where my most important claim comes from?

Write and revise a paragraph of your own

The case study question How many AI answers contain at least one unsupported claim? I compare answers to the same questions, first without and then with a request to cite the exact section of the IT service handbook.

What belongs in each part of the paper?

  1. Introduction

    What is the topic and what question will you answer?

  2. Methods

    Which sources did you use and how did you proceed?

  3. Results

    What did you find and where can readers check it?

  4. Discussion

    What does this mean for your question and what are the limits?

Four linked documents represent the introduction, methods, results and discussion.
Four linked documents represent the introduction, methods, results and discussion.

Follow the structure required by your assignment. Describe the method so someone else could reproduce it.

Outline an academic paper step by stepDOCX · Go to template

From finding to finished sentence

In the fictional data, 5 of 12 answers without a citation request contained at least one false claim or one the handbook could not support. With a citation request, the figure was 2 of 12. Both answers to the campus printing question said 50 MB. The IT service handbook allows up to 20 MB (p. 1, “Campus printing”).

The paragraph gives figures for the comparison and an example that shows where to check the error.

A results sentence states how many answers were affected, gives a concrete example and sets a limit on what the finding supports.
A results sentence states how many answers were affected, gives a concrete example and sets a limit on what the finding supports.

Connect the finding to the research question and to the source a reader can check.

Plan a paragraph with evidenceDOCX · Go to template

A fictional exchange to work through

My question for the AI

Where does my sentence “Citations prevent fabricated answers” go beyond our examples?
What the AI says
The AI suggests making a general claim about greater reliability.
How I check it
I report the two figures from the exercise and cite the exact answer sheet. My statement stays within the cases examined.
What I record
I record the feedback received and the sentence I wrote myself.

Does my claim go beyond the evidence?

“Citations make AI reliable” is a broad claim. This exercise shows what happened with twelve questions. The AI still said 50 MB for campus printing even when it cited a section. State what actually happened in the responses you checked.

The case compares fictional answers with and without a citation request. It does not test whether the IT service becomes more reliable.
The case compares fictional answers with and without a citation request. It does not test whether the IT service becomes more reliable.

Name the group and the figure you checked.

Check draft claims against their sourcesXLSX · Go to template

What should my figure caption say?

Example “Unsupported claims in AI answers to twelve IT service questions. Comparison with and without a citation request. Author's chart based on fictional examples.”

The bars show the groups, counts, totals and source of the answers.
The bars show the groups, counts, totals and source of the answers.

A caption explains the comparison and names the source, so the figure makes sense on its own.

Write a figure caption readers can verifyDOCX · Go to template

Exercise · Write a results sentence from the data

You plan to write “Citations prevent fabricated AI answers”. Revise it to fit the data. Include the figures and one case that illustrates the limit of the finding.

Plan a paragraph with evidenceDOCX · Go to template

Check what “prevent” implies

The wording is too strong. Even with a citation, the campus printing answer says 50 MB when the handbook allows only 20 MB.

Why? One such case disproves “prevent”. The data can separately answer whether fewer responses were affected and whether none were affected.

Write down the specific observation

In the fictional data, 5 of 12 answers without a citation request contained at least one false claim or one the handbook could not support. With a citation request, the figure was 2 of 12.

Why? The sentence explains what was counted and the number of answers per group. It avoids generalising across AI models or drawing conclusions about the university IT service.

Add a source and explain what it supports

Cite the example answer sheet after the figures. If you discuss campus printing, also cite the handbook passage that gives the 20 MB limit.

Why? The answer sheet makes the overall result reproducible. The handbook passage shows why this case was scored as an error. Readers can check both the calculation and the assessment.

Further reading

  • Human oversight, effective intervention and accountability in the use of AI.

    HUMAN OVERSIGHT

    AI oversight, intervention and accountability.IT, AI, GOVERNANCE & MANAGEMENT
    Who needs to review a recommendation, who can intervene, and when should an AI system be stopped? This book clarifies responsibility. It covers approval, oversight in operation and escalation, using an example of how customer enquiries are triaged.

Templates for this chapter

Plan a paragraph, check its evidence or finish your outline.

The guide and its figures are in English. The downloadable templates, handbook and example data are the German originals. In those files, “Campus printing” appears as “Campusdruck” and “With citation request” as “Mit Bitte um Fundstelle”.

  • Outline an academic paper step by step

    Give the introduction, methods, results and discussion distinct roles.

  • Plan a paragraph with evidence

    Build a paragraph from a claim, its evidence and your interpretation.

  • Check draft claims against their sources

    Check sentence by sentence what the cited source actually supports.

  • Address a finding that challenges your argument

    Work a contradictory finding into your argument.

  • Write a figure caption readers can verify

    Write the title, explanation and source for your chart.

  • Evaluate AI feedback and decide what to use

    Record which suggestion you checked and what you decided.

Your writing shows where the claims come from

  • Your question and method are clear.
  • Every important figure has an identifiable source.
  • You explain the limits of your findings.

Previous chapter

Signature of Dr Markus Groß

We use cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us to improve this site and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether you want to allow cookies or not. Please note that if you reject them, you may not be able to use all the functionalities of the site.

CookieHint and Consent by reDim GmbH (Opens in a new window)